Idea or Execution, a simple topic with complex factors working behind it. It started as a simple quest to figure out which one is more important, along the way I realized the complexity of the situation. I tried my best to put in simple way. Idea and execution, are the building blocks of everything we see around. We cannot neglect completely any one of them. So in each case to be successful they both have to be there. So, now the question rises which one of them is more important?.
Lets have a look.
In the most narrow sense, an idea is just whatever is before the mind when one thinks. Very often, ideas are construed as representational images-Wikipedia
The act of performing; of doing something successfully (dictionary)
Public Voting Result:
- In idea and execution which one is more important?
- idea (20%)
- execution (13%)
- more idea and acceptable execution (33%)
- more execution and acceptable idea (34%)
- How an idea must be thought?
- think wild (flying birds with no boundaries) (27%)
- follow the trend of market (7%)
- think idea first then find ways to execute (47%)
- think ideas but reject those you cannot execute (19%)
- You can be best defined as
- Student (40%)
- Designer (or related to field of design) (47%)
- Businessmen (13%)
- Work with Designers (0%)
- Teacher (0%)
- in above selected field for around
- 1 year (13%)
- 2-3 years (27%)
- 4-6 years (33%)
- 7-10 (13%)
- 10+ (14%)
Field Experts / Professionals Thought on the topic
A weak, simple or common idea is worth acceptable ….if executed well.
Mr. Yawwar Abbas, a very experienced teacher and Fellow of Higher Education Academy UK, replied . He carried on..
Idea is a chain reaction and that chain reaction is only possible when one starts the execution. A very unique idea will be dead if the execution is poor. Just like science every idea needs to be proved through a series of experiments….and that’s execution. An idea on paper is nothing, one has to give proof.
Mr. Jamshed Butt, CEO PGA Studio | Director PAF KIET College of Media & Arts gave his valuable thoughts,
It depends on target Market and approach, both Idea and execution must be there, and for ideas that change the world a visionary mind is absolute necessity
Mr. Ahsan Jabbar, Entrepreneur and CEO Global.pk, shed light from business side.
Execution is more important and it should be need based. Also it’s not what you do, it’s how you do it. Ideas mostly exist, but innovation can always be done. For example if we observe that middle eastern culture is more popular in our city and decide to open a restaurant on that theme, so idea of opening a restaurants not new in this case, but the execution can be.
Omer Tariq, graphic designer for over 8 years, explained beautifully.
I believe in “Great Idea, flawless execution
I’m speaking in terms of Advertising/Graphic design. A design with no idea and amazing execution is just an eye candy, it will grab attention but without a strong idea, general audience will not remember it, similarly a design with a great idea and terrible execution is just a waste, only a few people will be attracted towards it due to its clever thought.
There is no easy way if you want a successful design, it has to be a perfect Idea executed flawlessly, everything else is just an excuse.
In some forms of Art, like in Entertainment, Idea becomes more important. If you have a great idea in a movie, audience is willing to overlook the flawed execution. My suggestion is always to follow the rule of “Great Idea, flawless execution” wherever possible.
So, I hope situation is a little bit clear now. Idea do have its own power but without a tangible form to share / show or prove, it looses its strength. In some cases Idea plays big part and vice versa. Great idea and flawless execution should be our aim, and if we are determined to do something, new doors open for us.
With all that said, I would just like to add that people with vision, passion and die-for attitude not only think great ideas but also find the ways to execute, which brings question in our mind, how can they think of such a great idea?.
That was easy!
This is the complex part of Idea vs Execution. So read this only if you wish to go deeper into topic.
It amazed me a little when I discovered that quite a lot of marketing / branding factors and theories can be seen working behind the scene. Few things that effect the whole scenario:
- Need / Want
- Target Market
- When, Why, Where, Who, yes these factors effect a lot in real world.
- Luck ( this is a controversial element, you can agree or disagree with it)
- People who made fiction, a possibility, dozens of stories on Google
- Be S.M.A.R.T
- Creative thinking tips ( useful set of tips)
Note: All the conclusion are based on audience and experienced professionals views. Every aspect of human life is trial based, you will always have to try and figure out what is best for you. So if you have some different experiences, DO SHARE! with us for educational purposes.Special Thanks to all the participants and to respected professionals, who spend their valuable time to make this article Execute. Good luck executing!